Amy says Brad is lying.
Brad says Chris is lying.
Chris says both Amy and Brad are lying.
Who is lying? Who is telling the truth?
Click to see solution to Who is Lying?
Only Brad is telling the truth, Amy and Chris are lying.
The way to go about it is to look for a contradiction that proves one person is lying or telling the truth, and then follow the logic from there:
- If Chris were telling the truth (that both Amy and Brad are lying), Amy would be lying. But this would mean Brad is telling the truth, which contradicts Chris’s statement. So Chris must be lying.
- If Chris is lying, Brad must be telling the truth.
- If Brad is telling the truth, Amy must be lying.
Liked catching liars?
You might enjoy “Cold Case” Puzzles
Disclosure: The post contains affiliate links, through which I may earn a small fee if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
good
hi
Hi
brad
i think it is good but at the same time i think it is bad i don’t know which one should i chose
yo my name is freaking chloe to broooooo 🙂
brad
Brad
amy
I think it is all three or just brad because he is talking some
how to his friends like he wants them to lie and look inocient.
there is no i after c in innocent there is only 1 i in innocent
Amy
it is good
amy chris
brad
Brad is telling the truth and Amy and Chris are lying
they are all lying, the answer is incorrect
Chris
amy
amy and christ is lying
Brad is lying
brad is lying
i think who ever the first one who said it.
brad
i think it is Amy
I think that it is Chris, because if BOTH of the other people are lying, then HE must be the one lying.
this is okay but rlly EZ 2 figure out
I don’t think so
awesome
Totally Brad is telling the truth
SLAY GIRLY POP I THINK ITS AMY
ok I got it wrong its brad
really confusing got there in the end
I think this is stuped
It makes me sad
it has to be Amy and Brad Amy has her hands behind her back and Brad has a list of reasons
yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I did it i,m awesome!!
brad and amy
brad and amy are lying
Chris and Amy are lying. Brad is telling the truth.